Weak Governance Can Halve a Company’s Value, Botswana Investment Forum Panel Warns
Investors at the inaugural forum said they can live with risk they can price, but not with founder-only decision-making, patchy records or unclear ownership.
GABORONE – Businesses in Botswana that want outside capital risk losing much of their value if their management, controls and reporting are weak, finance specialists told the inaugural Botswana Investment Forum, The Business Weekly & Review reported on 11 November. Strong earnings alone are not enough, the panel said.
The session, Governance and Investment Readiness: Building Confidence, Protecting Capital and Driving Growth, was facilitated by Melissa Morapedi, a senior investment officer at the Botswana Development Corporation (BDC).
Highlights
- A panel at the inaugural Botswana Investment Forum warned that weak governance can sharply cut what investors will pay for a business.
- Alvarez & Marsal adviser Manuel Makki said a well-run firm with US$10 million of EBITDA might fetch eight times earnings, against four times for a poorly controlled one.
- BDC board chairperson Rizwan Desai listed concentrated decision-making, incomplete records and unclear ownership among the warning signs for investors.
- Fiducia managing director Thapelo Matsheka said basic financial controls should be in place long before a company grows large.
Risk investors cannot price
Manuel Makki, a senior adviser at Alvarez & Marsal Middle East and Africa, said investors are not afraid of risk as such, but of risks they cannot measure, manage or price. Poor structures and unreliable financial information raise the cost of capital or drive investors away, he said.
He used two hypothetical companies, each earning US$10 million before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation. A well-run firm might be valued at eight times earnings, or US$80 million, while one with weak controls might fetch four times, or US$40 million.
The warning signs
Rizwan Desai, BDC’s board chairperson and a founding partner of Desai Law Group, listed the red flags that put investors off. They include decision-making concentrated in one or two people, incomplete financial records, weak reporting, unresolved regulatory issues and unclear ownership.
Family-owned firms may eventually need to move beyond founder-led decisions, he said, and independent directors can bring experience and challenge. But he added that weak governance is sometimes simply an owner’s unwillingness to share control, which can stop a deal even when investors offer to help.
Start early
Thapelo Matsheka, managing director of Fiducia, said expansion plans need more than money. Companies also need capable managers, reliable systems and clear accountability.
He said smaller businesses should not wait to reach a certain size before putting in governance. Arrangements should be proportionate, but basic financial controls, defined responsibilities and oversight belong in place from the start.
The panel also stressed the role of audit, risk and human resources committees in spotting problems before they become crises. Panellists argued that good governance is a competitive advantage that can lower financing costs and lift a firm’s value, not merely a compliance burden.
Written by
Tumisang Bogwasi
Tumisang Bogwasi, Founder & CEO of Brimco. 2X Award-Winning Entrepreneur. It all started with a popsicle stand.
