Court of Appeal Rejects Manual Workers Union Bid to Halt Botswana’s Public Service Bargaining Council
The ruling lets the council that negotiates civil service pay keep working while the union pursues its challenge to the council's constitution and the appointment of its secretary.
GABORONE – Botswana’s Court of Appeal has dismissed an urgent application by the Manual Workers Union to stop the Public Service Bargaining Council (PSBC) from carrying on its business, the state news agency BOPA reported on 6 November. The ruling leaves the council, which is the forum where government and organised labour negotiate public service pay and conditions, free to proceed while the union’s wider challenge continues.
Justice Cameron, sitting as a single judge of the Court of Appeal, also dismissed the union’s request for an expedited appeal. He ruled that the balance of convenience favoured the bargaining council rather than the union, according to BOPA.
Highlights
- A single judge of Botswana’s Court of Appeal dismissed the Manual Workers Union’s urgent bid to stop the Public Service Bargaining Council from operating.
- Justice Cameron also refused to expedite the union’s appeal, ruling that the balance of convenience favoured the council.
- The High Court had earlier found the union was not a council member because it had not shown it met the 4,000-member threshold.
- The union’s substantive appeal, which asks for the council’s constitution to be declared void, remains a separate matter.
A second setback
The decision is the second loss in a row for the National Amalgamated Local, Central Government and Parastatal Workers Union, commonly known as the Manual Workers Union. On 16 October, High Court judge Professor Bugalo Maripe dismissed its challenge to the council, upholding the council’s constitution and its interim structures and finding that the union could apply for membership through the established procedures, BOPA reported.
The Business Weekly & Review reported that Justice Maripe held that, under sections 50(2) and 52 of the Public Service Act and the council’s constitution, membership required admission and proof of a 4,000-member threshold, which the union had not shown it met. The union had signed the constitution in May 2025 and again in October 2025, and was present when it was registered in November 2025, but the judge ruled that signing it did not amount to admission.
How the dispute started
The quarrel dates to a council meeting on 30 January 2026, when the PSBC appointed Andrew Motsamai as secretary and Tobokani Rari as deputy secretary. Manual Workers representatives walked out, refused to vote or sign the resolution, and later went to the High Court to have the meeting declared invalid.
What the union still wants
In its application for leave to appeal, reported by The Business Weekly & Review on 3 November, the union argues that the High Court created a circular trap by using a constitution it had signed to deny it standing. It asks the Court of Appeal to declare the PSBC constitution “incurably defective” and void or, alternatively, to set aside the 30 January meeting and the appointments of Motsamai and Rari.
The respondents include the Attorney General, the Botswana Teachers Union, the Botswana Public Employees Union and the Botswana Land Boards and Local Authorities Workers Union. Their position, as reported by the paper, is that the challenge is an afterthought by a union that lost a democratic vote.
What happens next
BOPA said the substantive appeal remains a separate matter. The ruling only removes the immediate threat of a court-ordered halt to the council’s work. No date for the hearing of the main appeal was given in the reports.
Sources
Written by
Tumisang Bogwasi
Tumisang Bogwasi, Founder & CEO of Brimco. 2X Award-Winning Entrepreneur. It all started with a popsicle stand.

