Africa Markets

Nigerian Insurance Stocks Slide Even as Nine-Month Profits Surge

The NGX Insurance Index is down 13.64% this year while the All-Share Index is up 60%, as dilution from recapitalisation, investment-led earnings and weak cash flow weigh on valuations.

The trading floor of the Nigerian Exchange in Lagos
Photo: S.aderogba / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0) (file)

LAGOS – Nigeria’s listed insurers have delivered a run of earnings beats in the third-quarter results season, but their shares have mostly fallen, leaving the sector among the cheapest on the Nigerian Exchange (NGX), according to a Nairametrics analysis.

Highlights

  • The NGX Insurance Index is down 13.64% in 2026, against a 60% ASI gain.
  • AXA Mansard’s nine-month profit after tax rose 81% to N10.9 billion.
  • AIICO, Custodian and AXA Mansard trade at about 5.6 to 7.2 times earnings.
  • Dilution, investment-led profits and weak cash flow explain much of the gap.

Profits up, prices down

AIICO Insurance reported a 27% rise in nine-month pre-tax profit to N19.4 billion, and its profit after tax of N17.3 billion beat its own forecast. Its shares fell 6.6% that day. AXA Mansard’s profit after tax rose 81% to N10.9 billion, more than double its forecast, while Coronation Insurance’s profit rose 71%.

NEM Insurance earned N26.8 billion in nine months, more than its total for 2025.

Yet AXA Mansard traded around N11.65 in early November, about 15% below its opening price for the year. Coronation has fallen by about a third and Cornerstone by about 24%. The Insurance Index fell 5.52% in October and is the only major NGX sector index in negative territory for 2026.

The banking index is up 60% and the oil and gas index 128%.

The reversal is sharp. Insurance stocks returned about 66% in 2025, beating the All-Share Index’s 51%.

Why investors are wary

The analysis points to three concerns.

Dilution. The Nigerian Insurance Industry Reform Act 2025 gave insurers until July 2026 to meet higher minimum capital, set at N10 billion for life insurers, N15 billion for non-life insurers and N35 billion for reinsurers. Many raised the money by issuing shares, and the regulator says 43 insurers and reinsurers complied.

Coronation’s share count rose by almost a fifth, and AXA Mansard shareholders approved a rights issue of up to N18.3 billion.

Earnings quality. Much of this year’s profit growth came from investment income on high-yielding bonds and Treasury bills rather than underwriting. At AIICO, the underwriting margin slipped to about 8%.

Cash. Some profits have not turned into cash. NEM’s operating cash flow swung to an outflow of N1.1 billion as premiums owed by customers rose to N9.5 billion.

Why it matters

Based on annualised nine-month earnings, the sector’s valuations imply double-digit earnings yields for companies with returns on equity ranging from about 13% to nearly 38%. Whether that is a mispricing or a fair discount depends on whether underwriting improves once bond yields ease.

For investors across African markets, the episode shows how recapitalisation drives can weigh on share prices even when they strengthen balance sheets.

Sources

Filed under

Africa Markets

Written by

Tumisang Bogwasi

Tumisang Bogwasi, Founder & CEO of Brimco. 2X Award-Winning Entrepreneur. It all started with a popsicle stand.

More from this writer