Africa Insurance

Only 6% of South Africa’s Road Accident Fund Payouts Go to Medical Care, Study Finds

Actuaries say more spending on early treatment could shrink costly loss-of-income claims at the fund, whose net liabilities have reached R439.5 billion.

Traffic on the N1 highway near Midrand, heading to Johannesburg
Motorists on the N1 near Midrand, Gauteng. Photo: Marco Scholtz / Wikimedia Commons (public domain) (file)

CAPE TOWN – Less than a tenth of South Africa’s Road Accident Fund (RAF) payouts go to medical care, according to an actuarial study presented at the Actuarial Society of South Africa (ASSA) convention. The authors argue that spending more on early treatment could reduce loss-of-income claims and the fund’s overall costs, Moneyweb reported.

Highlights

  • Just 6% of RAF payouts went to medical care.
  • Loss-of-income claims took 53% of payments.
  • The fund’s net liabilities stand at R439.5 billion.
  • Government is weighing a hybrid model to ease the fuel levy.

Where the money goes

Of claims paid between 2019 and 2023, loss of income accounted for 53%, general damages 28%, legal fees 13% and medical care 6%, said Gregory Whittaker of Algorithm Consultants & Actuaries, one of the authors.

“Medical care is the one benefit that can make all the other bits of damage smaller. Treat someone early, and they lose less income,” he said. About 80% of road accident victims are treated in public hospitals, which the RAF seldom reimburses, shifting much of the cost to the health budget and medical schemes.

Rising costs, falling capacity

The estimated cost of accidents in a single year rose 4.3 times in real terms, from R20.6 billion in 2010 to R89.3 billion in 2020. Whittaker said this was not due to more accidents. He pointed instead to more loss-of-income claims, awards based on potential rather than likely earnings, and weak defence of claims, including default judgments.

The fund finalised just over 100,000 claims in 2020 but only about 18,000 in 2024. Its assets as a share of outstanding claims fell from 44% in 1985, under its predecessor, to 3% in 2020.

The funding debate

The RAF is funded through a fuel levy of about R2.25 a litre. Transport Minister Barbara Creecy has ruled out raising it. In October, Deputy Minister Mkhuleko Hlengwa told Moneyweb he favours a hybrid model in which the levy is reduced but not scrapped, alongside third-party vehicle insurance and travel insurance for foreign visitors.

The study also favoured a hybrid of the RAF, the shelved Road Accident Benefit Scheme and compulsory third-party insurance, backed by governance reform and actuarial oversight.

Why it matters

The levy adds to fuel prices for every motorist and business, and the fund’s liabilities are a growing contingent risk for the state. Electric vehicles could also erode levy income over time. Reforms that shift spending toward early treatment and tighter claims control could ease pressure on both public finances and pump prices.

Sources

Filed under

Africa Insurance

Written by

Tumisang Bogwasi

Tumisang Bogwasi, Founder & CEO of Brimco. 2X Award-Winning Entrepreneur. It all started with a popsicle stand.

More from this writer