Shoprite CEO Share Award Passes Despite 46% of Ordinary Shareholders Voting Against
Christo Wiese's high-voting deferred shares carried a plan worth about R176 million to retain Pieter Engelbrecht for six years.
CAPE TOWN – Shoprite Holdings’ special share award for chief executive Pieter Engelbrecht was approved at the retailer’s annual general meeting on 6 November, but about 46% of ordinary shareholders voted against it, according to the group’s results announcement and Moneyweb.
Highlights
- CEO share plan passed with 70.91% of combined votes.
- Only 53.81% of ordinary shares supported the award.
- Award of 525,000 performance shares valued at over R176 million.
- Proxy advisers ISS and Glass Lewis had recommended rejection.
How the vote passed
The CEO Executive Share Plan needed a simple majority. It received 70.91% support once deferred shares held by founder Christo Wiese were counted. Those shares, issued in 2000 at a nominal 0.1c each, give Wiese about 32.2% of voting rights while he owns about 10.68% of the company, Moneyweb reported.
They lapse if his stake drops below 10%.
Among ordinary shares alone, support was 53.81% against 46.19% opposed, according to the SENS announcement.
What the award is for
Engelbrecht will receive 525,000 performance shares, worth more than R176 million at the current share price. Shoprite said the plan was “designed to incentivise the successful delivery of a unique combination of strategic, transformational and succession-related outcomes” and to secure his employment for six years.
The company pointed to his 29 years of service and said “significant shareholder value has been created during the CEO’s tenure”.
Why advisers objected
Institutional Shareholder Services and Glass Lewis urged investors to vote against. According to Bloomberg, ISS said Shoprite had not given a compelling enough rationale for another large incentive, and also objected to a “sales growth modifier” that triggered a full short-term bonus despite below-threshold performance.
The remuneration report drew 22.83% opposition. Under amended Companies Act rules, these votes are now binding but need only a simple majority.
Why it matters
Shoprite is Africa’s largest food retailer, and investors are watching succession closely: Spar, Pick n Pay and Boxer have all named new chief executives. The vote shows how dual-class voting can override a large minority of ordinary holders. Institutional investors may keep raising pay and governance concerns at future meetings.
Sources
- Moneyweb: Revolt as Shoprite shareholders slam CEO bonus award
- IOL: Shoprite CEO pay policy faces shareholder backlash
- Shoprite SENS: AGM results
Written by
Tumisang Bogwasi
Tumisang Bogwasi, Founder & CEO of Brimco. 2X Award-Winning Entrepreneur. It all started with a popsicle stand.
